Located in the heart of Old San Juan, 257 San Justo Street presents a rare opportunity to own a distinctive property in one of Puerto Rico’s most celebrated historic districts. Surrounded by Spanish colonial architecture, colorful buildings, and charming cobblestone streets, this beautifully maintained residence combines historic character with versatile spaces suited to a variety of uses.

Spanning approximately 5,337 square feet across two levels, the property showcases a traditional façade with wrought-iron balconies and partial views of San Juan Bay. Originally built in 1900, the property preserves the architectural charm of Old San Juan while incorporating modern conveniences and thoughtfully maintained interiors.

The first floor features an elegant open-concept space with exposed wooden beams and refined marble flooring, currently serving as an art gallery. Recently renovated powder rooms add contemporary comfort, while a stunning interior courtyard beneath a skylight roof creates a memorable focal point. Complete with a captivating fountain, living plant wall, and full wet bar, the courtyard offers an inviting setting for gatherings, entertaining, or a potential café concept.

A full commercial kitchen at the rear of the property connects to the upper level, providing additional flexibility for events and hospitality-oriented uses. The combination of open spaces, distinctive architectural details, and entertaining areas creates an exceptional environment for creative or commercial-style activities, subject to applicable zoning and approvals.

The second floor offers a warmer, more residential atmosphere with added privacy. A welcoming foyer leads into a generously sized great room featuring wide-plank wood flooring and large windows that fill the space with natural light. A balcony overlooking San Justo Street provides partial views of the bay, further enhancing the property's distinctive character.

Additional features include mini-split air conditioning, turnkey furnishings, a concrete structure, and the potential to develop a rooftop area, subject to feasibility and necessary approvals. The property's mixed zoning adds to its versatility for prospective buyers exploring residential, gallery, hospitality, or other permitted uses.

For buyers seeking an even larger presence in Old San Juan, the neighboring property at 255 San Justo Street is also available for purchase at $849,000, offering a potential opportunity to acquire both properties.

Combining historic architecture, distinctive interior spaces, partial bay views, and flexible use potential, 257 San Justo Street represents a unique opportunity in the heart of Old San Juan.

Asking Price: $3,400,000

Property Taxes: $3,847.11 annually (2026 tax year).

Property Details: 5,337 sq. ft. | Built in 1900 | 4 full bathrooms | Mixed zoning